My theorie!

Ok i think Dudley is a wizard! I Think that Petunia noticed strange things happening in Dudley's first year of life, so she contacted Dumbledore (not sure how she knew to contact him). Dumbledore confirmed her fears in the 'last' letter and somehow placed a spell over Dudley so he couldn't use his magic, therefore he wouldn't find out about it. He also kept him off the Hogwart's list, so Dudley didn't get the letter at age 11. If Harry is no longer welcome in the house, Dudley will find out he is a wizard and so will Uncle Vernon. I think this is Petunia's worst nightmare.

When dumbledore went to the Dursley's in the Half Blood Prince, he said that they harmed Dudley. I think it's because they have shielded him from his wizarding side.

And in the 5 book, he senses a demendor,which only wizzard can see.
Its probaly all rubish though!

Muggles can't see dementors but they sense them.
As for the rest of it, hm... Need to think about that.

Better get thinking again

That's really interesting... but as Jenn said, Muggles can sense a Dementor... and I believe that when Dumbledore said that they harmed Dudley, he meant that the way he was brought up wasn't like other kids, he had everything when he wanted to have it, no one taught him to try to get things he wanted. the only thing he knew how to do was moaning... but life isn't just moaning to your parents for a new toy or anything... it's much more difficult...

Jennn wrote:Muggles can't see dementors but they sense them.
As for the rest of it, hm... Need to think about that.

Y'all know I was joking about that last line right?

Nice and creative theories, but Dudley is a muggle. When I wrote that Dumbledore said that Dudley's parents spoiled him, I meant that they spoiled him by over pampering him as in giving him whatever he wants, even if it is bad for him.

nymphadora wrote:That's really interesting... but as Jenn said, Muggles can sense a Dementor... and I believe that when Dumbledore said that they harmed Dudley, he meant that the way he was brought up wasn't like other kids, he had everything when he wanted to have it, no one taught him to try to get things he wanted. the only thing he knew how to do was moaning... but life isn't just moaning to your parents for a new toy or anything... it's much more difficult...

^ Same thinking xD

Hey!..

It is a possibility i suppose?

Hmm, interresting.

But, yeah kinda strange topic. But I do not think that Dudley is a Wizard. He is too much of a tub too be one. Haha. :lol!:

^

Ohhh Burnn XD

I think it would be cool if Dudley had some magical abilities though, it would be interesting to see how Petunia handled her oh-so-perfect Dudleykins being "one of them".